Skip to content

D&D Fifth Edition is coming, players asked to guide remake

nytimes.com
8 pointsTashtego3 comments
On HN

Comments

UUuuugghhh, not another new version of D&D. This crap is exactly the reason I'm so down on playing. I spent a ton of money on AD&D 2nd Ed. stuff back in the mid 90's when I was playing a lot... then I took a few years off from playing, and when I looked at it again, v3.5 was out. Fine, I figured that was fair, a few years had gone by and 2nd ed was pretty dated.

But right after I spent another ton of money on v3 and v3.5 materials, they announce 4th edition! WTF?!? I resisted even touching that edition until last year when I caved in and bought a player handbook and rolled out a character for an impromptu game with a few friends one weekend. And now they want to roll out yet another new version?

Please... I know there's pressure to rev stuff in order to sell more copies of the core rulebooks, but WotC are - IMO - shooting themselves in the foot with the constant version changes. I'm sorry, but I'm not throwing out and replacing a big investment in D&D materials every 4 years or so.

Seriously Wizards, if you want more of my money, you'd be better served pushing out more material for an existing D&D version (preferably 3.5). Give us an updated Ravenloft campaign setting and related stuff, give us a modern Planescape, create entirely new realms (have you done anything completely new since Eberron?), etc.

OK, rant over. :-)

I thought the last sentence of the NYT article was priceless- currently, the only way anyone is bringing D&D material to the table on an iPad is if they steal it, because Wizards still doesn't sell any core digital content (magazine articles and access to a rules website you can get for a monthly subscription, but no books)

I'd be absolutely willing to buy more 3.5e material.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.