Skip to content

Ask HN: Legality of using previously open source data?

1 pointvfulco22 comments
On HN

To protect the innocent/guilty, I won't name the company here.

1. Need a data source, which previously was open for commercial use, for one of my MVP features

2. After a merger, company now offers a "no-cost" license to use so long as proper attribution is given and brief approval process is completed. Have been talking with them off/on multiple times for 12 months to gain access. Seems I am too small a company for them to really pay attention to regardless of their public statements re: access. I have even asked them to come up with a "per api call" fee that was fair to both parties (until I can get bigger and pay their ~$5K average minimum fee) but no luck so far.

3. Came across an academic study on github which used this company's data from 1 year ago.

Am I allowed to use the old data set for my internal research and commercial purposes? I only want to do the right thing.

Thanks in advance!

Comments

I'm not an expert, but I think it depends on the license. My understanding is that some licenses are revocable and some aren't.

Contact an intellectual property lawyer.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.