Skip to content

Ask HN: Email client with an opt-in inbox?

2 pointsnend5 comments
On HN

I'm tired of a cluttered inbox, but also tired of:

- manually unsubscribing from newsletters I don't remember signing up for

- managing folders, tags, etc.

- allowing for-profit entities the power to divert my attention whenever they want

Are there any email clients with an opt-in inbox? Meaning all emails go to blocked/triage/queue unless I specifically approve them for my inbox, or similar. I want my life uncluttered, I want to be stingy with where I place my attention.

I remember vaguely hearing about this kind of email inbox over the years, but I wasn't able to find any existing providers when I went to search for one this morning. Is anyone using a system like this, any suggestions?

Comments

I want one that bounces spam emails instead of just deleting them.

If people use a deliverability service they get punished worse for having a high bounce rate than they do for having a high complaint rate. I want to see more punishment.

What I do is I reject (with an error message) all messages not sent to an address in the /etc/aliases file. I will add a new alias for each correspondent. If there is spam (or otherwise too many undesired messages which cannot be removed), then I will delete the alias. Additionally, I do not have HTML email; it is purely plain text, and ASCII only (no Unicode). I use the "exim" email software on my computer to do this. This has worked; I only very very rarely receive any spam (less often than once a year).

I have my own mailserver with sieve filtering. It would be possible to create that with sieve, but it requires constant updates to add an domain.

hey.com -- it's not a client but it's a service that has the feature you want.

nendOP

Huh interesting, that does look promising, thanks.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.