Skip to content

Ask HN: Does the broken windows theory apply to online discussions/comments?

1 pointabhishekbasu1 comment
On HN

I have observed (empirically) that independent of the platform or specific type of content, all it takes for an discussion to get ugly/ irrelevant is a handful of comments that are beside the point or funny. I realize that the extent of disarray depends on factors such as moderation, vote/rank systems, etc. But I was wondering if there is an analogue of the broken windows theory for this phenomenon?

Comments

It's bikeshedding. It's easier for any given person to comment on the joke or insult or cultural reference than the main subject, and the extra comments derail the discussion.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.