Skip to content

Aliens Riding Meteorites: David Dobbs on the Journal of Cosmology

wired.com
29 pointschalst6 comments
On HN

Comments

Reporters typically say "interesting" when they're afraid of being sued for saying "nutbag crackpot".

I just hope those scientists are careful about introducing alien bacteria to Earth's ecosystem.

If we find an alien bug via a meteorite, then that bug was one of the reigning champions in terms of ability to survive and subdue its opponents. It would have the capability of subduing our entire ecosystem leaving humans scrambling to try to remove it, contain it, then adapt to protect against it.

The traits that allow something to survive extended periods in space don't automatically grant it the traits that would allow it to thrive on Earth above all else.

Look at Earth's extremophiles, the bacteria that can survive near thermal vents on the ocean floor, extended trips in space/vacuum, intense radiation, sub-zero temps, etc, there's no evidence that they're taking over the non-extreme locations. Even if they do survive outside their "home" environment, that doesn't automatically make them the top dog that will edge out everything else.

The article is about fossils found in meteorites that have been on earth for a very long time.

I'm not worried about fossilized bacteria taking over Earth's ecosystem.

"If we find an alien bug via a meteorite, then that bug was one of the reigning champions in terms of ability to survive and subdue its opponents."

That doesn't mean it's some kind of super-bug. The dodo survived long enough and I'd hardly call it a reigning champion. In the bacterial sense, there are plenty of harmless bacteria as well.

Maybe humans are not native to this planet. Maybe we came from one such meteorite. :)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.