Skip to content

The God Project — Hinduism as an open source faith

huffingtonpost.com
4 pointslut4rp1 comment
On HN

Comments

I think he's painting a bit too open and free picture of Hinduism here. Also, the consistent superlatives used in describing the "glorious" open-source Hinduism and the "closed-source" Western/Middle-Eastern religions is a bit drab. He seems like he wants to capitalize on the goodness that is associated with the term "open-source" and link that goodness to Hinduism, and associate the negativity associated to "close-source" with Western/Middle-Eastern religions. They shouldn't be compared like this without painting a false picture.

There are many sects within Hinduism = true. There are many sects within nearly any other religion = true. Should you be able to add something to the body of a religion without any push-back? Can you? I doubt it and it would be silly if you could. Can you do that to any open-source project? Nope, unless you fork, and at that point it's a new "sect" or possibly "religion" anyway.

If you must compare them, they are simply different levels of open.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.